The central question

Would you create the same power if your most distrusted opponent were certain to inherit it?

Change the officeholder, preserve the rule, and watch what happens to your judgment.

Try it

Nothing changes except who wins.

Imagine a governing coalition can reshape an institution without meaningful opposition. Choose who controls it.

Your side holds the power.

The proposal may feel efficient, necessary, and overdue. Now identify the institution that can still review, delay, narrow, or reverse the decision.

The complete test

Six questions before the rule changes.

Where does authority move?

Identify the institution gaining practical power—not only the public objective used to justify it.

What independent institution loses power?

Every transfer has two sides. Name the court, legislature, executive, state, union, owner, voter, press institution, or opposition group that becomes less capable of resistance.

Who selects the new decision-makers?

Trace appointment, election, membership, funding, removal, and internal accountability.

What can still say no?

A safeguard must possess legal authority, resources, information, and sufficient independence to exercise it.

Can a future majority reverse the change?

Measure the legal, political, financial, and organizational cost of restoration.

Would you accept the same power in hostile hands?

If changing the officeholder changes the answer, the objection concerns power—not merely personality.

Why it matters

The test slows down the moment when urgency is most persuasive.

Concentrated power can produce fast results. It can also weaken the institutions needed to correct error, protect minorities, expose corruption, and replace leadership peacefully.

The test does not settle every policy question. It separates the desired outcome from the mechanism and forces the mechanism to survive a change in who controls it.

See the evidence standard